Sunday, September 20, 2015

Ethical Opportunism

It’s seems to me that at some point in a person’s life, they will be undoubtedly faced with an opportunity that would benefit them, but wouldn’t be entirely ethical.  Sometimes, the line between ethical and unethical can be distinct, and in others it may be blurred.  What factors affect this?  The person making this decision may not have a strong moral conscience.  Maybe they were not raised to adhere to the strictest of moral standards, or maybe they have found that exercising a lax conscience has given them a competitive advantage against other more morally responsible people.  

An example of this that immediately comes to mind is when a person is in debt to an acquaintance.  Some parents instill in their children a sense that when a debt is owed, it must be payed back in full as soon as possible.  Others may not stress this as much, and the child may not understand the social/legal benefits of doing so (in the social sense, that you are a trustworthy and responsible person; in the legal sense this could be connected to your credit score).  Of course, most know that an immediate payment of a debt it very much appreciated by the person to whom the debt is owed.  But imagine a situation where the indebted would benefit by waiting longer than they should to eliminate their debt.  Maybe the loaner is forgetful, and/or doesn’t pressure the indebted for the money (they don’t need the money immediately, it’s a small amount of money, etc.).  It would be opportunistic for the indebted to not pay up.  They may think, “good things come to those who wait”, although that is a twisted interpretation of the saying (in my opinion). 

To cite a specific example, I have a friend who lived with one other roommate last year.  Each month, this person was in charge of paying the entire television/internet bill, and the other roommate would pay their share of the bill to him personally.  He would pay the bill on time (by automatic payments online), and then report to the other how much was owed.  He wouldn’t pressure his roommate to pay him, but made sure he was aware of the debt.   The roommate was, without fail, very late on his payments.  Even though a debt was owed, he would not go out of his way to repay it.  The indebted in this situation would receive money from his parents to pay for the bill, but he would spend it on other things, and therefore would claim to have to ‘wait’ longer before asking his parents for money again, less they become suspect of his devious actions. 


My friend who payed the bill did so with his parents money, and wasn’t pressured  by his parents for the money from his roommate as he paid each bill (he would collect it over the semester and pay back a total).   So it begs the question, how unethical was the ‘late payer’ really being?  He was being opportunistic by not spending the money when he had to, and using it for his own personal gain, while not doing much harm to his roommate.  The possible disadvantages of this strategy, however, are a reputation for late payments and a loss of a trust.

1 comment:

  1. I'm reading and commenting on this Monday morning. The post came in yesterday after I was done commenting on other blog posts. This time, you are getting the benefit of the doubt. Please in the future get the post done earlier.

    In your story there is a very practical question - how late is late? There is also a related question, why was the person late with the repayment? If the roommate was on a tight budget and didn't have the funds to pay the share of the bill on time, that offers one explanation. If the roommate was simply forgetful, this is a mild form of negligence that I believe many teens have. If sometimes the roommate didn't pay the share at all and multiple requests needed to made to elicit payment, then that sounds opportunistic.

    It is awkward when roommates or housemates interact but where they come from families who are quite different income-wise. Is the fair thing to share expenses down the middle? What about sharing them where the richer roommate bears a bigger burden? If that issue is underlying the lateness in the payments its resolution would help to understand the situation better.

    ReplyDelete